Trade Advice

[khandog25]

Wussup fellas... got a serious trade goin on right now, and am really not sure what to do....here is my team at the moment

we start a qb, two rb's, three WR's, one TE, one TE/WR, and one RB/WR, K, Def

QB: Anderson, O'sullivan
RB: Portis, Lynch, Perry, taylor
WR: Burress, Andre Johnson, Fitzgerald, Desean Jackson, Cotchery
TE: Rosario
K: Gould
DEF: Atlanta, just picked em up because of the matchup against the chiefs

As you can i am stacked at the wideout position, and i would say my RB's are pretty solid, but my weak point is at the QB position...here is the trade i have been proposed
Giving up: Portis, D. Jackson, anderson
Getting: Rivers, Braylon Edwards

I need a qb, my qbs have let me down thus far, but my team has held up for the most part. Should i give up one of my solid rb's for a rivers that seems to be airing it out quite a bit, and get an edwards to a already stacked wideout position. What do yall think, really appreciate the advice guys:howdy:

 

[Whisperz]

Hate that trade for you.

It does make your QB better but it doesn't make your team better. Edwards has struggled and dropped tons of passes this year and lets not forget the guy is not a proven reciever. His high praise is based solely on his breakout year last year.

I would go find a guy with a solid QB on the bench and offer him Cotchery and Taylor for maybe Eli Manning or someone in the 8-15 QB range.

BTW I think Anderson will get back on track. He has gone up against the Steelers in the mud and the Cowboys in Week 1. Give him 2 weeks.

 

[JakeT.]

That's a horrible trade for you. You downgrade your QB spot, your RBs will be crap, and the upgrade at WR is almost pointless since you will now have to bench Deshean who is stupid but productive. Very bad idea.

 

[renz]

Anderson > Cry baby RIVERS!

That trade is horrible i agree with the guys here. stick with ur team. If anything i would try to grab a TE or a better back to go along with portis and lynch.

I wouldnt give up anyone except cotchery, desean, perry and taylor tho becuz you have a good looking team.

 

[khandog25]

awesome, thanks for the comments guys. They all make quite sense, shouldnt have even thought about that trade. The advice is much appreciated

 

[FairWarning]

See if Fasano or the Carlson is available and drop Rosario, now that Steve Smith is back.

 

[khandog25]

the only TE i see worth picking up at the moment is O. Daniels for Houston. U guys see any value in hiM?

 

[mcpaul]

don't do it.

 

[FairWarning]

the only TE i see worth picking up at the moment is O. Daniels for Houston. U guys see any value in hiM?

YES. Also an advantage that he had his bye-week already.